Differenze
Queste sono le differenze tra la revisione selezionata e la versione attuale della pagina.
| Entrambe le parti precedenti la revisione Revisione precedente Prossima revisione | Revisione precedente Ultima revisione Entrambe le parti successive la revisione | ||
|
cms:exo-16-025 [02/11/2016 14:57] argiro |
cms:exo-16-025 [04/11/2016 07:08] arcidiac |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Linea 1: | Linea 1: | ||
| http://cms.cern.ch/cds/EXO-16-025 | http://cms.cern.ch/cds/EXO-16-025 | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===== da Stefano ==== | ||
| Dear authors, ARC, congratulations on this well-written, clear paper. Below we have some questions/comments to your attention. | Dear authors, ARC, congratulations on this well-written, clear paper. Below we have some questions/comments to your attention. | ||
| Linea 44: | Linea 46: | ||
| Table 2 : In this form, the table is quite confusing. It is not clear if the "magnitude" column is the relative uncertainty on sigma x BR or on the quantity indicated by the last column. In the first case, I would remove the last column. For the label of the second column "Magnitude" is best described as "relative uncertainty" . In the caption: " the second column, the third column indicates " -> there is an offset in the column count, "Source" is the first column, therefore "Affected quantity" is the fourth, not the third, and "Effect on yield" is the third, not the second. | Table 2 : In this form, the table is quite confusing. It is not clear if the "magnitude" column is the relative uncertainty on sigma x BR or on the quantity indicated by the last column. In the first case, I would remove the last column. For the label of the second column "Magnitude" is best described as "relative uncertainty" . In the caption: " the second column, the third column indicates " -> there is an offset in the column count, "Source" is the first column, therefore "Affected quantity" is the fourth, not the third, and "Effect on yield" is the third, not the second. | ||
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | |||
| + | |||